Selection of Q&A’s from Swans Trust Members Facebook Event- 15th October 2020

Hi all, welcome to this evening’s Q&A session and thanks for attending and being a member of the Swans Trust!  

Please ask any questions on this thread and I’ll respond accordingly. We have some previously submitted questions  we’ll add into this chat as we progress. Thanks! 

  1. Question previously submitted by Gwyn John “Hello Andrew, there appears to be much action this week on  transfers in and out, as a Trust are we ever informed in advance of any changes pending in the playing staff and  where this will take us. Obviously this is a concerning time for the fans who have witnessed a good start to the  season but we would quickly come unstuck if we lose players, and faces are brought in which are simply not good  enough.” 
  1. Thanks Gwyn. Stuart McDonald, our Supporter Director, meets with the club’s management team, such as Julian  Winter and Gareth Davies (our CFO) every week, so is kept abreast of the general situation. Things can move quickly  so we’re not consulted on individual signings but we are aware of the general plans. 

Obviously, we share our views and the fans concerns on various things. For example, on the Joe Rodon situation we  all see the press reports of Spurs coming in with an offer we’d see as ridiculously low, and that opinion is shared. We  understand that view is shared by the club. If we received an offer we couldn’t refuse then obviously we would need  to replace and strengthen the squad. It is the challenge for Julian and his team, so we will see! 

  1. Hi Andy, what dialogue has Trust had to date with Jake Silverstein? 
  2. Hi Ian. Funnily enough, we had our first conversation with Jake Silverstein this evening. It was very civil and he  came across well but obviously we shared our concerns with how the recent board changes have been handled and  the general lack of communication, which has been a historic issue. Of course, we also told him all about the historic  issues between us and the other shareholders. We shall see how that progresses, but it was a generally positive first  meeting. 
  3. good news that the dialogue has started 
  4. Agreed. Long overdue. 
  5. With the Swans Facebook page recently sharing a petition to allow fans to return to stadiums, have the club  considered any way that they would be able to manage this if the government decide to consider it? Any  suggestions over percentage attendance that could be safely managed, or thoughts on what could be sufficient to  put in place to allow a return, if the government agree? 
  6. Unfortunately, at the moment, there are a lot of unknowns. We know the UK, and Welsh, Governments are not  countenancing fans attending sports stadia at the current time, and what that phased return would look like needs to  be agreed between the clubs and the Governments. I don’t think there’s been enough engagement in that area to be  honest. 

I know the club have done some work to look at how they can facilitate that, but unfortunately, I don’t think we’re  close to returning. We also have the local lockdown situation as well of course. 

  1. Dear Trust, Due to Swansea’s remarkable recent history and pleasing playing style, Swansea City has fans from  across the UK and indeed worldwide. What actions are the Trust taking to engage and inform fans beyond press  releases? With fans obviously not able to physically engage with the Trust because of Covid-19, I think this is a  pressing issue. I appreciate this Facebook Q and A is a positive step in this direction. One suggestion I would have  is could the trust co-ordinate / organise a virtual fan night over zoom? Something akin to Swansea City Pub Quiz  or perhaps talks about the history of the club. Thanks. Tom
  2. It’s a good idea Tom! Today is just an attempt to kick things off. We’ll see if this works and go from there. Maybe a  Teams/Zoom call for a Forum could work too, or maybe something in the social area. We’ll have a think and go from  there, but this is definitely something we want to improve upon. 
  3. The trust has been offering a 50% discount on trust membership to new members recently. Has there been an  increase in people joining since the discount was offered? 
  4. Yes there has been a very positive take-up. We have over 300 new members in the last couple of months, so thank  you all who have re-joined, and of course thanks all to those who had joined previously who we automatically  extended for this season! 
  5. With Jenkins and Morgan still listed as directors, what part of any do they still play in the club? Do they still  attend board meetings, meet with Silverstein/Winter etc? 
  6. I don’t think HJ has attended a board meeting since he resigned as Chairman. MM does though, and I know he’s  often there on matchday. In terms of involvement, I’m sure he also speaks to JW and JS too, but to what level he  speaks to other shareholders I couldn’t really comment. As he is a director of the club, that’s not surprising though I’m  sure. 
  7. Next question previously submitted is from Richard … “Thanks for this, good to see you’re doing it. I am not  sure if I’ll be able to attend but hope that someone will ask if we can take a position on the ‘Project Big Picture’  idea as I see many supporters’ groups have taken a position (against) this idea? All the best” 
  8. Thanks Richard. It seems this has been kicked into the long grass as the PL clubs have rejected the proposals, but  we shall see what comes of the next few weeks. 

We’ve just sent out a statement to members on what we see as the pressing issues. The current crisis means that  many clubs, particularly in L1/2 are weeks away from being unable to pay the bills. They need urgent support, so a  financial package is something that needs resolving very quickly. We see that short-term loans have been offered but  that doesn’t resolve the issue. 

I think we’d be dead against anything that impacts a team’s ability to progress through the leagues. Promotion and  relegation are the lifeblood of the league and must always be in place. 

Something we’ve called out on many occasions is the need for proper, independent governance of the football  industry in this country. Clubs can’t be trusted to just do the right thing, and often need protecting from themselves.  The UK government promised a fan-led review of football and governance prior to the election and we urge them to  honour that commitment. It is needed now more than ever. 

  1. It appeared initially as if there wasn’t going to be a Swans/Poppy Badge this year but It looks as if common  sense has now prevailed. 
  2. I’m glad that was resolved, and seems there was a bit of a missed communication as to why it was missed in the  first place.
  3. Hi Andy How has the pandemic impacted on the Trust’s schools’ initiative which seemed to have gained a lot of  support locally. Alan. 
  4. Hi Alan, good to see you! At the moment, school visits are not practical, so things are generally on hold until  schools are able to engage more fully. Roger, as our lead on this, is keeping engaged with the schools but we are  rather limited in the current climate unfortunately, but it remains very much central to what we want to do going  forward. 
  5. A question received from Barry earlier….”The posters on my small forum feel, rightly or wrongly, that the Trust  is proving toothless in respect of the proposed action/litigation against the owners. So, my question on their  behalf is – when can we expect real progress in this respect? 

Thank you again. 

  1. Hi Barry. Hope my earlier answer covers where we are on this. Appreciate it can seem like this has dragged on, and  it has, however unfortunately a lot of the necessary steps in order to proceed with this in the correct way take a lot of  time, and that situation has been exacerbated in recent months. 

I can assure you we are still very much committed to the process mandated by our members and we are progressing  it as quickly as we can. I hope that increased communication will help our members understand the progress made  and the timelines. I would hope we can conclude the remain step in the next few weeks but just like any negotiation it  can take longer than we would wish. 

  1. This is from Tim….. “Dear Trust. I think I’ve been a member of the Trust since its inception and, in an ideal  world, would like to see the club owned 100% by our supporters. 

A couple of questions about the progress of possible legal proceedings against the current / former owners. 

I disagreed with the Trust’s decision to seek to force the sale of Trust shares to the current or former owners, and  still do. The decision seems contrary to a number of the stated aims of the Trust, 

(I can’t see how forcing present / past owners to purchase our shares squares with our stated aim to ‘maintain  and increase a stake in the club’). I thought that there were other stated Trust Aims that the process also  contradicts, but these seem to have changed on the website. Have any modifications been made recently to the  Trust’s aims, as advertised on the Trust website and, if so, was there a mandate for the changes? 

  1. Hi Tim, thanks for your questions! I’ll answer as detailed as I can. 

In terms of costs to date, our annual accounts which are published on our website show the financial position of the  Trust at the end of each financial year, which include the outgoings, which largely relate to legal costs. At the current  time, our costs in relation to overall legal expenses are around the £250k mark. 

Hi all, it looks like we have come to the end of the questions, so I’ll wrap things up now. Thanks all for attending and  let us know how you think this evening as gone, whether it is helpful, how it can be improved etc. 

I’ll answer any further questions when I see them, but thanks all for attending! 

Andy Godden 

15th October 2020

Latest News